If I correctly understanding your idea, I think, after start of this new rule you'll greatly reduce inflow of new members and Nutters will become closed elitist community which is doomed to death without fresh blood. This is a dead end road.
This is what I meant as well.
I don't think there is much to be read without logging in. We could probably move some threads to the open forums as there is much game content that is offlimits for unregistered players because it is in the same section as some private stuff and the whole section has been "classified".
Or we could make only 1 section that is private and move all the stuff there. Why should your private data be all over the place and mark its surrounding topics as "private data"???
And what exactly do you refer to? If you expect people to introduce themselves with photos included you should keep photos thread open ... or you don't want that?
I am getting confused. I demand a drawn flowchart of how you imagine the path of a new user to the point of having access to everything.
please do be careful what you post. There are nutters about hehe.